STP Execution: How Forex Brokers Manage Their Risk

The terms "STP" and "A-Book" are often misunderstood or used interchangeably in forex trading. While both models transfer market risk, they differ significantly in how orders are executed. Let’s dive into the mechanics of Straight-Through Processing (STP) and its distinction from A-Book execution.

What is STP?

“Straight-Through Processing” (STP) was originally a term from electronic trading, describing the process of automating trade execution to reduce errors, paperwork, and human intervention. With STP, transactions are processed electronically from start to finish, optimizing speed and minimizing operational risks.

However, in the retail forex industry, the term has evolved into a marketing tool. Brokers often use "STP" to imply that they do not interfere with or benefit from customer trades.

A-Book vs. STP Execution

Although both A-Book and STP execution transfer market risk, they operate differently:

A-Book Execution (Post-Trade Hedging):

The broker executes the customer’s trade first and then hedges the position with a liquidity provider (LP).Known as post-trade hedging, this method results in faster execution and minimal slippage for customers.

STP Execution (Pre-Trade Hedging):

The broker secures a matching order with the LP first, then executes the customer’s trade.Known as pre-trade hedging, this method can result in slower execution and higher slippage for customers.

How STP Execution Works

When a broker uses STP execution:

It ensures it can secure a better price from the LP before confirming the customer’s trade.This eliminates the broker’s risk of slippage but increases the likelihood of slippage for the customer.

For example:

A broker quotes a buy price for EUR/USD at 1.1000.Before confirming the customer’s trade, the broker ensures it can buy from the LP at a better price, say 1.0999.

If the price changes during this process, the customer’s order will execute at the new price, which may result in positive slippage (a better price) or negative slippage (a worse price).

Slippage in STP Execution

Slippage occurs when there is a difference between the requested price and the actual execution price.

Causes of Slippage:

Rapid market movements, often due to news or economic events.Delays in order transmission between the broker and LP.

Impact on Customers:

Slippage can be positive or negative, meaning the executed price may be better or worse than expected.Customers can set “bounds” on their orders to limit the range of acceptable execution prices.

Why Brokers Use STP Execution

The primary advantage of STP for brokers is the elimination of slippage risk on their side. By securing a price from the LP before confirming the customer’s trade, the broker avoids potential losses from unfavorable price movements.

However, this process can:

Increase slippage for customers.Slow down order execution due to the additional step of confirming the LP’s trade.

Riskless Principal Transactions

Trades executed via STP are often referred to as riskless principal or matched principal transactions.

In these transactions, the broker acts as a counterparty to the customer’s trade while simultaneously securing an offsetting position with an LP.The broker does not assume market risk but instead facilitates the trade by “matching” the customer’s order with an LP’s price.

Key Differences Between A-Book and STP

AspectA-BookSTPHedging TypePost-trade hedgingPre-trade hedgingExecution SpeedFasterSlowerCustomer SlippageMinimalHigher probabilityBroker Slippage RiskPresentEliminated

Conclusion

While both A-Book and STP execution models transfer market risk, they cater to different priorities.

A-Book Execution: Focuses on faster execution and minimal slippage for customers.STP Execution: Protects brokers from slippage risk but increases the likelihood of slippage for customers.

Understanding these differences can help traders make informed decisions about the type of broker and execution model that best suits their needs.

STP Execution: How Forex Brokers Manage Their Risk

Password Reset

Password Reset

You are already logged in

Forex Basics: What you need to know

How do you Trade Forex

When Can You Trade Forex?

Who Trades Forex

Why Trade Forex

Margin Trading 101: Understand How Your Margin Account Works

Forex Brokers 101

Types of Chart

Understanding Japanese Candlesticks

Introduction to Fibonacci Trading

Moving Averages Explained

Popular Chart Indicators